The Orchard Sox Apple Tree Pest Challenge

Sox Vs. Sandwich Bags Vs. Gift Bags

How Do You Fight Back Against Apple Tree Pests?

What do you do when insect pests destroy the apples on your apple tree? You can get mad – or you can get even by applying insect barriers like Orchard Sox to prevent bugs from laying their eggs under the skin of the growing fruit on your tree.

That was Donna Lockey’s approach. The artist from the Kawartha Lakes region of Ontario, Canada, decided to do a little experiment, comparing three ways of protecting the apples growing on her tree.

Her goal was to protect the fruit before the insect pests got a chance to do their damage. So, in the early spring, when the baby apples on her Royal Gala apple tree were about an inch (2.5 cm) in diameter, she applied an insect barrier on each little fruitlet.

Three ways to protect growing fruit from insect damage: plastic sandwich bags, Orchard Sox, and gift bags from the dollar store. (Photo Credit Donna Lockey)

Three ways to protect growing fruit from insect damage: plastic sandwich bags, Orchard Sox, and gift bags. (Photo Credit Donna Lockey)

When it comes to barriers to protect your apple tree fruit from insect and pest damage, there are different options. Donna chose three to try this year. And some of the fruit she left uncovered to compare how the unprotected fruit fared.

The Royal Gala apples that were not protected by orchard sox, sandwich bags, or gift bags look a little worse for wear. (Photo credit: Donna Lockey)

The Royal Gala apples that were not protected by orchard sox, sandwich bags, or gift bags look a little worse for wear. (Photo credit: Donna Lockey)

For protection, she used:

  • Orchard Sox, little nylon sockets that, when tied onto baby fruit, expand as the fruit grows, protecting it from insect damage.
  • Sandwich bags, zipping the fruitlets into these little plastic bags.
  • Gift bags from the dollar store, which have an easy pull that you can tie to keep the bag securely on the fruit. Perhaps she was inspired by The Daily Bread Orchard’s designer apples?

Best Pest Protection? Orchard Sox vs. Sandwich Bags vs. Gift Bags

Orchard Sox

Sandwich Bags

Gift Bags

So far this year Donna harvested 15 pounds of apples from her tree. Here she describes her results:

“The socks worked well. There were a few bird damaged ones and bugs got in on those ones.   As the socks grew with the apples the ends opened up.  Next year I plan on using clothespins to keep that twist tight, rather than twisting and tucking them in on themselves.”

“The sandwich bags worked okay. Earwigs were able to get in still and a big ol’ spider, probably from the cut corners.”

“The party favour bags worked well, but I doubt you could put them on large size apples. Pulling the ties closed was fast and easy.”

Donna was super happy with the results, even though her friendly neighborhood earwigs managed to munch their way past some of the barriers to destroy a further five pounds of fruit. Thanks Donna for sharing your story and your pictures!

There’s lots more to learn about protecting your fruit trees from pests and disease. Check out the podcast below, peruse my fruit tree care blog, or sign up for my online training course in Beginner Fruit Tree Care. Enjoy!


Susan Poizner

Susan Poizner

Director, Fruit Tree Care Education Online

Susan Poizner is the author of the award-winning fruit tree care book Growing Urban Orchards,  creator of the award-winning online fruit tree care training at, and host of’s  Urban Forestry Radio Show. Susan grows fruit trees in Toronto, Canada.

Recent Blogs

Grower Profile: Jeanne Calabrese

Grower Profile: Meet Jeanne Calabrese of Chicago, a home grower who has turned her yard into a beautiful and productive orchard.

Getting to know the bugs in your orchard

Getting to know the bugs in your orchard is critical if you’re going to be able to care for your fruit trees. Get a glimpse into their world in this blog.

Learning From Tree Leaves

Tree leaves can indicate nutritional deficiencies and pest and disease problems. Learn how to understand what they are saying.

How Do You Celebrate Podcast and Website Awards? and The Urban Forestry Radio Show have both won Silver Awards of Achievement from the GWA (Association of Garden Communicators)…how do you celebrate?

When it comes to fruit tree skills, practice makes perfect!

When it comes to fruit tree care skills, practice makes perfect. That’s what the interns have discovered who are involved in the the fruit tree care internship project at San Romanoway in Toronto’s Jane and Finch area.

Red Deer Community Orchards Thrive With The Help of City Staff

Red Deer Alberta becomes an edible city under the guidance of city staff trained in specialist fruit tree care.

Jesuit Pear Trees – Is it time to bring back this heirloom tree?

Jesuit Pear Trees produce pears that are sweet, spicy and very rare. This cultivar has been growing in North America since the 1700s and it is disease resistant. Is it time for a Jesuit Pear revival?

Recycling Urban Trees

Sometimes a tree comes to the end of its life due to old age or sickness, and it can be heartbreaking to send it to the chipper. A project in Virginia is working hard to link up arborists, foresters, millers and artisan woodworks to save trees from that sad fate.

Edible Community Garden Grant: Free Fruit Trees – And Fruit Tree Care Training

Get Free Fruit Trees and Free Fruit Tree Training for your group. Apply for the TreeMobile Edible Community Garden Grant (For those in Toronto, Richmond Hill, Guelph and Cambridge Ontario).

Fertilizer Focus: Is Chicken Manure Good For Fruit Trees

Is chicken manure good for fruit trees? Not always. Read this blog to find on when to use this popular fertilizer.